The Lost Art of the Horror Soundtrack: How Music Once Made Movies Truly Terrifying

There was a time when a horror movie didn’t need CGI monsters or endless jump scares to make you shiver. All it took was a few notes, played slowly, deliberately, with just the right dissonance, to crawl under your skin. The golden age of horror soundtracks, spanning roughly from the late 1960s through the 1980s, gave us some of the most chilling and iconic scores ever written. But somewhere along the way, horror music changed. Maybe it lost something… maybe we all did.

When Sound Became Fear

Before audiences ever saw a drop of blood in Psycho (1960), Bernard Herrmann’s shrieking violins had already done half the job. Those stabbing strings were the knife, sharp, metallic, merciless. That score changed everything. It told filmmakers and composers that horror didn’t just live in what we saw, it lived in what we heard.

In the years that followed, composers became the unseen monsters behind the screen. Goblin’s prog-rock score for Suspiria (1977) turned witchcraft into a psychedelic fever dream. John Carpenter’s minimalist synths in Halloween (1978) transformed a simple piano riff into a universal heartbeat of dread. Even The Exorcist (1973), with its deceptively calm “Tubular Bells,” made the ordinary sound otherworldly.

Each of these scores wasn’t just background noise, they were characters. They guided emotion, anticipation, and terror more effectively than dialogue ever could.

Analog Fear: The Power of Imperfection

What made those classic soundtracks so potent was their analog nature. Tape hiss, imperfect tuning, distorted synths, all of it added texture. It sounded human, or sometimes inhuman in the best way.

Modern horror often leans on digital perfection or ambient drones. But there was something about those analog imperfections that stirred our primal fears. Goblin’s chaotic layering in Suspiria feels almost ritualistic, like you’re listening to a ceremony that shouldn’t be heard. Carpenter’s music feels mechanical and alive at the same time, like the pulse of a machine stalking its prey.

Even lesser-known composers of the time, like Fabio Frizzi (The Beyond, City of the Living Dead) or Joe Renzetti (Dead & Buried), crafted soundscapes that sound haunted simply because of their production limits. Their music feels trapped, alive in old film reels and vinyl records, whispering from a forgotten frequency.

When Horror Got Too Loud

Something changed in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Big studio horror turned up the volume. Soundtracks became bombastic, overloaded with orchestral hits and “stinger” sounds timed to jump scares. It was effective, but it wasn’t haunting.

Where once the soundtrack created unease through restraint, modern horror often uses sound as a bludgeon. You don’t feel scared because your brain is processing atmosphere, you feel startled because something just screamed at you.

That subtle dread, the kind that crawled up your spine while you watched The Omen or Rosemary’s Baby, has become rare. It’s not that today’s composers lack talent (far from it), but rather that horror’s commercial formula doesn’t leave much room for quiet terror anymore.

A Revival in the Shadows

But all is not lost. The retro-horror renaissance has brought soundtracks back into focus. The success of films like It Follows, The Witch, and Hereditary shows that audiences crave that creeping unease again. And much of it comes from the music.

Disasterpeace’s score for It Follows channels Carpenter with its minimalist synths but layers in a modern unease. Mark Korven’s The Witch and The Lighthouse use primitive instruments and unsettling drones that sound like the earth itself groaning.

Then there are modern artists like Mica Levi (Under the Skin) or Colin Stetson (Hereditary), who use sound to evoke dread on a physical level, music that’s almost too strange to classify, too uncomfortable to ignore.

Even outside of cinema, horror-inspired musicians are resurrecting the form. Bands like Carpenter Brut, Perturbator, and John Carpenter himself have found cult followings with their dark synthwave albums. Their music proves that horror’s sound still has fangs—it just needed to escape Hollywood’s formula.

Listening to Fear

Try this experiment: turn off the lights, put on headphones, and play the Suspiria soundtrack at low volume. You’ll feel the air shift around you. The whispers, the percussion, the otherworldly moaning, it's an auditory séance.

Or listen to Halloween’s main theme, stripped of the movie visuals. You’ll feel stalked by nothing more than rhythm and repetition. That’s the magic of these compositions—they don’t just accompany fear, they create it.

Horror soundtracks remind us that sound is often scarier than sight. You can close your eyes,

but you can’t close your ears.

The Future Sounds of Fear

As independent horror continues to thrive, it’s likely that the art of the soundtrack will continue its eerie comeback. Digital tools now let artists mimic vintage analog warmth, or twist it into something entirely new. We may be entering another golden age, one where fear once again vibrates through our speakers instead of just flashing across the screen.

For horror fans and creators alike, revisiting those old soundtracks isn’t just a nostalgic trip, it’s an education in subtlety. Music doesn’t just decorate horror, it defines it.

When Herrmann’s violins sliced through Psycho, when Goblin’s whispers filled Suspiria, and when Carpenter’s synths stalked the night, they were telling us a truth that every horror lover knows deep down:Sometimes, it’s what you hear that kills you.

Be sure to pre-order (or buy) my DEVOURED sequel - The Witch of November - coming Halloween 2025.

Or check out my short story of ghostly horror - 3:33

And if you want to see all of my work in one place visit my online bookstore today.