Why Authors Should Be Free to Write Beyond Their Own Experiences

I have no idea what this is - Thanks Wix AI. Thought it was funny though.

In a world where representation and authenticity matter more than ever, it’s become increasingly common to hear discussions about whether authors should “stay in their lane” when it comes to writing about characters, experiences, or identities different from their own.

Should a male author write a female protagonist? Can a writer who has never battled addiction authentically depict a character struggling with alcoholism? These questions have sparked passionate debates in writing communities, publishing circles, and reader groups alike.

But here’s the truth: fiction, at its core, is an act of imagination. While sensitivity and research are essential, limiting what writers can explore stifles creativity and threatens the richness of storytelling.

The Role of Imagination in Fiction Writing

One of the most powerful tools an author has is their imagination. Writers build entire worlds, create fantastical creatures, and invent experiences far beyond their personal realities. If we only wrote about what we directly know, we’d lose the very essence of what makes fiction captivating.

Think about the science fiction author who writes about life on other planets. Or the thriller writer who creates a convincing serial killer despite never having committed a crime. These stories don’t suffer from a lack of personal experience—they thrive on imaginative engagement, careful research, and empathetic insight.

Writing Is Research

While personal experience can add depth, it’s not a requirement for writing compelling and truthful fiction. Many successful authors spend months or even years researching topics to ensure accuracy and authenticity in their work. Whether it’s understanding the symptoms and treatment of PTSD, the cultural nuances of another country, or the psychology of addiction, authors frequently become temporary experts in subjects they’ve never personally lived.

Writers interview people, read memoirs, consult professionals, and study histories to build well-rounded characters and realistic narratives. In fact, the desire to understand and empathize with other experiences is one of the hallmarks of good storytelling.

I think most authors are like sponges. We are constantly observing and watching things, and taking that in. It allows us to delve into ideas that are beyond our current situation. Writing, without imagination, is boring! You have to delve into things that may be controversial to stay relevant.

Writing Across Gender, Identity, and Experience

A frequent point of contention is when authors write characters of a different gender, race, orientation, or cultural background. It’s important to acknowledge that these are sensitive areas and can carry the potential for harm if approached carelessly. However, writing across difference is not inherently wrong.

What matters is how it’s done.

When male authors write female characters (and vice versa), or when authors write characters from different walks of life, they’re engaging with the world’s diversity through empathy and creative exploration. The key is respectful representation. That means avoiding harmful stereotypes, doing meaningful research, listening to lived experiences, and—when appropriate—working with sensitivity readers or cultural consultants.

Great literature is full of characters who differ from their creators, and many readers treasure these stories precisely because they offer insight into lives unlike their own. For example, Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird features a young female narrator and explores themes of racial injustice—subjects far removed from many writers’ personal lives but handled with empathy and lasting impact.

Fiction as a Bridge Between Experiences

One of the beautiful things about fiction is its ability to build bridges. It invites readers to walk in someone else’s shoes and see the world through a different lens. Authors don’t need to have lived every detail they write—what they need is the skill and commitment to write it with care and emotional truth.

Toni Morrison once said, “You don’t have to love your characters. But you have to know them.” That knowing doesn’t necessarily come from personal experience; it comes from observation, compassion, and a deep commitment to storytelling craft.

Fear of Backlash Can Lead to Creative Paralysis

Some writers today hesitate to write outside of their own experiences out of fear of criticism or being “canceled.” While these concerns are understandable in today’s charged social media landscape, they shouldn’t override the core mission of fiction: to tell meaningful stories.

Creative writing should not be reduced to autobiography. If we insist that only people who have directly experienced something can write about it, we are essentially advocating for a type of creative gatekeeping that would rob readers of many beloved books.

Of course, this doesn’t give authors a pass to write irresponsibly. Poorly researched, insensitive, or exploitative portrayals should rightly be critiqued. But when authors approach their work with integrity, curiosity, and empathy, they should be encouraged—not condemned—for trying to write beyond themselves.

Encouraging Diverse Storytelling Without Censorship

Championing diverse voices is essential in modern literature. Encouraging more authors from underrepresented communities to tell their own stories is long overdue. But promoting diversity and protecting creative freedom are not mutually exclusive.

We can—and should—make space for more voices without silencing authors who strive to write respectfully and inclusively about topics they haven’t personally experienced. The literary world is big enough for all kinds of stories told from all kinds of perspectives.

Final Thoughts: Trust the Reader, Trust the Writer

Ultimately, storytelling is a shared experience between the writer and the reader. Readers are capable of discerning whether a story feels authentic, well-researched, and emotionally honest. Authors should be trusted to do the work necessary to tell those stories with care.

To limit writers to only what they have directly experienced is to reduce fiction to memoir. It denies the transformative power of imagination—the very thing that allows us to connect, to explore, and to understand each other better through the written word.

As long as authors are writing with respect, empathy, and a commitment to truth—even if it’s not their truth—they should be encouraged to write boldly, bravely, and without fear.

Be sure to get a copy of my latest cult horror tale - The Given - out now!

And visit my online store for all of my works in all formats in one convenient place.