Horror has always been a battleground of blood, guts, and controversy. Whether it’s the moral panics of the past or the endless debates over which subgenres deserve respect, fans and critics alike have strong opinions about what defines “true” horror. In recent years, the term “elevated horror” has taken center stage, causing a major rift in the horror community. Some argue that it’s breathing new life into the genre, while others claim it’s watering down the raw, unapologetic terror that horror fans crave. So, is elevated horror saving the genre—or killing it?
What Is Elevated Horror, Anyway?
The term “elevated horror” is often used to describe horror films and novels that focus more on psychological depth, social commentary, and artistic execution rather than traditional horror tropes like jump scares, gore, and supernatural frights. Think Hereditary (2018), The Witch (2015), and The Babadook (2014)—movies that prioritize atmosphere, storytelling, and deeper themes over outright shock value. In literature, authors like Paul Tremblay (The Cabin at the End of the World), Hailey Piper (Queen of Teeth), and Victor LaValle (The Changeling) have been pushing the boundaries of horror with cerebral, often emotionally devastating narratives.
This shift has been widely praised by mainstream critics, who have historically dismissed horror as a “lowbrow” genre. Now, horror films are being nominated for Oscars (Get Out, The Silence of the Lambs), and horror novels are winning prestigious literary awards. For many, this newfound respectability is a victory. But not everyone is thrilled about it.
The Argument for Elevated Horror
Proponents of elevated horror argue that the genre has always been about more than just scares and gore. Classic horror films like The Shining (1980) and Rosemary’s Baby (1968) were deeply psychological and thematically rich, yet they were still considered horror. The recent wave of elevated horror simply continues that tradition, proving that horror can be both terrifying and intellectually engaging.
Elevated horror also broadens the genre’s appeal. Many viewers who previously dismissed horror as too gratuitous or shallow have been drawn in by films and books that explore social issues, grief, trauma, and existential dread in innovative ways. This shift has brought more serious discussion and analysis to horror, reinforcing its artistic legitimacy. And let’s be honest—horror could always use a bigger audience.
The Backlash: Is Horror Losing Its Edge?
However, not everyone is on board with the rise of elevated horror. Hardcore horror fans argue that the term itself is condescending, as if traditional horror—the kind that embraces blood, guts, and relentless terror—is somehow “lesser.” Movies like Terrifier 2, Evil Dead Rise, and Barbarian prove that audiences still crave intense, no-holds-barred horror. So why does elevated horror get all the critical love while slashers, creature features, and supernatural horror are often dismissed?
There’s also the fear that studios and publishers will prioritize prestige horror over the wild, boundary-pushing horror that has defined the genre for decades. Horror is meant to shock, disturb, and challenge societal norms. If every horror film or book must now be a metaphor for trauma or a political statement, are we losing the sheer, unfiltered fear that makes horror so thrilling?
Can Both Styles Coexist?
The good news is that horror has always been a vast and diverse genre, capable of accommodating multiple styles. Just as the 80s saw both high-art horror (The Thing, The Fly) and full-throttle gorefests (Friday the 13th, Hellraiser), today’s horror landscape is equally varied. Elevated horror may be getting the critical spotlight, but there’s no shortage of brutal, terrifying films and books for those who prefer their horror with more teeth.
Filmmakers like Jordan Peele (Nope, Us) and Zach Cregger (Barbarian) are proving that horror can be both intelligent and absolutely terrifying. Meanwhile, authors like Clive Barker, Stephen Graham Jones, and Eric LaRocca continue to push the boundaries of horror fiction in wildly different ways. There’s room for both elevated horror and the blood-soaked nightmares that keep fans up at night.
The Final Verdict
So, is elevated horror saving or killing the genre? The answer depends on who you ask. If you love thought-provoking, atmospheric horror that lingers in your mind long after the credits roll, elevated horror is a dream come true. But if you’re a fan of raw, relentless horror that doesn’t apologize for being shocking and brutal, the rise of elevated horror may feel like an attack on what made the genre great in the first place.
Ultimately, horror thrives on evolution. As long as there are creators willing to push boundaries—whether through sophisticated psychological horror or splatter-filled carnage—horror will never die. The real question is: what scares you the most?
Be sure to check out my terrifying sci-fi horror novella Obsidian, at Amazon!
Or just visit my online bookstore and find all of my work in all formats!
Comments