The Most Insane Pulp Plots Ever Written

Pulp fiction was never about restraint. It was about grabbing the reader by the throat on page one and never letting go. Writers were paid by the word, deadlines were brutal, competition was fierce, and subtlety was a luxury no one could afford. The result? Some of the most outrageous, imaginative, and gloriously insane plots ever committed to print.

While modern thrillers often strive for realism and plausibility, the pulps asked a different question entirely: How far can we push this before the reader’s jaw hits the floor? Cities were wiped out. Madmen declared war on civilization. Monsters stalked alleyways. Entire populations were hypnotized, gassed, frozen, or driven mad, sometimes all in the same story.

These weren’t just mysteries or adventures. They were events. And the wildness of their plots is a big reason pulp fiction is still remembered, and still beloved, nearly a century later.

Let’s dive into the most insane pulp plots ever written, and why they worked.

When Pulp Decided to Destroy Entire Cities

One of the most striking things about pulp fiction is its total lack of hesitation when it comes to scale. Modern writers often flinch at mass destruction. Pulp writers embraced it.

Nowhere is this clearer than in The Spider series. Written primarily by Norvell Page, these stories routinely opened with entire cities on the brink of annihilation. Poison gas attacks wiped out neighborhoods. Plagues spread faster than anyone could stop them. Riots erupted as panic consumed the streets.

In one story, criminals unleash a nerve gas that causes people to kill themselves in droves. In another, an entire city is thrown into chaos by a villain who seems able to control death itself. These plots weren’t metaphors, they were bonfires.

The insanity wasn’t just the destruction. It was the commitment. Pulp writers didn’t tease catastrophe. They delivered it.

Mad Scientists Who Declared War on Humanity

If pulp fiction loved one type of villain above all others, it was the mad scientist, and these weren’t quirky eccentrics. These were men (and occasionally women) who wanted to reshape the world through terror and technology.

Doc Savage faced an endless parade of brilliant lunatics wielding:

• weather control machines

• mind-control rays

• biological weapons

• machines that erased free will

• devices capable of collapsing governments overnight

In some stories, entire populations were hypnotized into obedience. In others, villains attempted to turn humanity into a new species under their control.

What makes these plots insane isn’t just the technology; it’s the confidence. These villains never thought small. They didn’t want riches. They wanted dominion.

Modern supervillains owe everything to these pulp madmen.

Criminal Masterminds With Plans So Wild They Defied Logic

Pulp villains didn’t just commit crimes. They staged performances.

In The Shadow’s stories, villains often orchestrated crimes like theatrical productions. Entire crime waves were illusions. Killers turned out to be multiple people sharing one identity. Gangs were controlled by voices heard only over the radio. Criminal empires operated behind layers of false fronts, secret tunnels, and coded messages.

One particularly wild plot involves criminals faking supernatural phenomena to terrify the public into submission. Another features a villain who manipulates the stock market through staged murders designed to cause panic.

These plots often made no sense if examined too closely, but they didn’t need to. They moved fast, hit hard, and kept readers breathless.

Logic was optional. Momentum was mandatory.

The Spider: When Pulp Went Fully Apocalyptic

It’s impossible to talk about insane pulp plots without giving The Spider his own spotlight. No other pulp hero waded through body counts like this character.

The Spider’s stories regularly included:

• tens of thousands of deaths

• entire cities on fire

• villains who made Hitler look restrained

• mass hysteria as a narrative tool

In one story, a villain unleashes a gas that causes people to die with frozen grins carved into their faces. In another, criminals take over entire city systems and turn public infrastructure into weapons.

These weren’t crime stories, they were urban apocalypse fantasies. And readers loved them.

The Spider proved that pulp could go bigger, darker, and more violent than anyone expected, and survive.

The “Everyone Is Already Dead” Twist

One of pulp fiction’s most disturbing tricks was revealing, late in the story, that the disaster had already happened.

Characters would discover:

• the city was already doomed

• the population had already been infected

• the villain had already won, temporarily

The hero’s job wasn’t to prevent catastrophe, but to undo it or mitigate the damage. This narrative move created enormous tension and made victories feel earned.

Modern horror and thriller fiction still uses this trick constantly, pulp popularized it.

Lost Worlds, Hidden Civilizations, and Underground Empires

Pulp fiction loved secret places. Beneath cities, beyond jungles, inside mountains, entire civilizations waited to be discovered.

Stories featured:

• underground empires with their own technology

• lost civilizations ruling the modern world from the shadows

• hidden societies manipulating global events

• ancient monsters awakening in forgotten ruins

These plots blurred the line between crime, adventure, and horror. One moment the hero was tracking a gangster; the next he was battling a cult worshipping a pre-human god beneath Manhattan.

Insane? Absolutely.Memorable? Without question.

Why These Insane Plots Worked

Despite their excess, pulp plots succeeded for a few key reasons:

1. They Matched the Stakes of Their Heroes

Pulp heroes were larger than life, so the threats had to be equally massive.

2. They Reflected Real Fears

Economic collapse, war, technological anxiety, loss of control; pulp plots exaggerated real-world fears into spectacle.

3. They Never Apologized

Pulp fiction never stopped to explain itself. It barreled forward with confidence.

4. They Were Fun

Above all else, pulp plots entertained. They shocked. They thrilled. They delivered.

Why Modern Writers Still Chase Pulp Madness

Today’s writers often rediscover pulp when realism feels restrictive. Pulp reminds us that fiction can be:

• outrageous

• bold

• unapologetic

• imaginative

• excessive

Modern audiences still respond to that energy, especially when it’s handled with craft and intention.

New Pulp writers embrace the insanity while grounding characters emotionally. That balance is pulp’s greatest gift to modern storytelling.

Final Thought: Pulp Went Big So Fiction Could Dream Bigger

The most insane pulp plots weren’t mistakes. They were declarations.

They said: Storytelling doesn’t need permission.They said: Go bigger.They said: Shock the reader.They said: Have fun.

And because pulp dared to go too far, modern fiction knows just how far it can go.

Be sure to read my detective series and follow Deklan Falls here.

Or you can follow my own pulp hero called The Revenant over at Amazon.