The Horror Author’s Guide to Disturbing Your Readers in All the Right Ways

Let’s be honest — horror fans are a different breed. We don’t just want to be scared. We want to be unsettled. We crave the stuff that burrows under the skin and stays with us long after we’ve closed the book or turned off the movie.

That’s the secret to writing disturbing horror fiction. It’s not just gore. It’s not just monsters or mayhem. It’s about creating discomfort that lingers, horror that sticks like a cold sweat in the middle of the night.

If you’re a horror writer (or just a horror fan who wants to understand what makes a story really hit hard), this guide is for you. Here’s how to disturb your readers in all the right ways — ethically, effectively, and terrifyingly.

Disturbing Horror Isn’t Just About Shock Value

The rookie mistake? Thinking disturbing horror is just about being gross. Sure, splatterpunk has its place, but what truly gets under the skin isn’t buckets of blood — it’s emotional discomfort.

Great disturbing horror doesn’t scream. It whispers.

The key is to create moments where your reader feels emotionally exposed, like the story is speaking directly to their fears, regrets, or unresolved trauma. That’s the stuff that hits deep.

1. Dig Into Real-Life Fear First

The most disturbing horror doesn’t come from the supernatural. It comes from real human experiences — grief, abuse, shame, isolation, loss, helplessness.

Look at:

• The Babadook → Grief and motherhood

• Hereditary → Generational trauma

• The Girl Next Door → Real-world cruelty

• Pet Sematary → The unbearable grief of losing a child

These stories work because they weaponize emotional truth. The scares are metaphors. If you want to disturb your reader, start by identifying a universal human fear — then layer your horror on top of that.

2. Create Uncertainty — and Keep the Reader Off-Balance

The most disturbing horror fiction doesn’t explain everything. It makes the reader question what’s real and what isn’t. It plays with ambiguity.

You can do this through:

• Unreliable narrators

• Nonlinear storytelling

• Minimal exposition

• Subverting expectations

Think House of Leaves, A Head Full of Ghosts, or The Ritual. The unease comes from not knowing what’s safe or true. That uncertainty builds dread more effectively than any jump scare.

3. Use the Body — But Do It With Purpose

Yes, body horror works. Mutation, infection, transformation — we’re deeply uncomfortable with losing control over our own flesh. But the best body horror isn’t just grotesque — it’s thematic.

• Cronenberg’s The Fly isn’t just gross. It’s about aging, illness, and decay.

• Raw isn’t just about cannibalism. It’s about sexual awakening and identity.

• The Troop isn’t just parasites. It’s control vs. helplessness.

If you’re going to be gross, be smart about it. Let the horror say something.

4. Make Your Reader Complicit

This one’s advanced — but devastatingly effective. If you want to write disturbing horror that really lingers, try this: make the reader feel like an accomplice.

Let them:

• Root for the wrong character.

• Laugh before realizing it was inappropriate.

• Watch something awful without being able to look away.

• Participate in something dark — even if just through silence.

Books like The Wasp Factory, We Need to Talk About Kevin, or Gone to See the River Man do this brilliantly. It creates a moral unease that readers carry with them long after the final page.

5. Reflect the Reader’s Darkness Back at Them

We’re all scared of something — but we’re really scared of what we might be capable of.

The most haunting stories aren’t about monsters. They’re about the potential for monstrosity within us. Tap into that.

Ask:

• What would it take for an ordinary person to do something terrible?

• What happens when someone embraces their worst impulses?

• Can a reader sympathize with someone doing something awful?

Think American Psycho, The Road, or The Secret History. These aren’t just scary — they’re disturbing, because they hold up a mirror and ask: Is this you? Could this be you?

Bonus Tip: Use Restraint to Amplify Impact

Don’t go full horror 100% of the time. The best disturbing horror knows when to pull back. Create contrast. Give the reader a moment to breathe — then pull the rug out.

The quiet moments make the horror louder.

Think of it like music: silence between the notes creates rhythm and tension. In fiction, downtime between the disturbing moments creates anticipation, unease, and emotional build-up.

But a Quick Word of Warning…

Disturbing horror isn’t about trauma-dumping or being offensive just for shock. Respect your readers. Push boundaries, yes — but do so with intent.

If you’re going to tackle dark topics (abuse, violence, suicide, etc.), do your research. Know why you’re using it. Know how it serves the theme, plot, or emotional arc.

Horror can be transgressive — but it should never be thoughtless.

Final Thought: Horror That Lingers Is Horror That Matters

When readers say a horror story “messed them up,” it’s usually because the story hit something true. It made them feel seen — even in the darkest way. That’s the power of disturbing horror fiction. That’s what makes it stick.

If you’re a horror author, never be afraid to go deep. Dig past the guts and ghosts. Go straight for the emotional jugular. Make them squirm. Make them question. Make them feel haunted — not just scared.

Because horror that disturbs? That’s the kind of horror people never forget.

A terrifying encounter in outer space - that's my new sci-fi novella Obsidian out now!

Or visit my entire online bookstore and see all of my work in all formats.