top of page

The Ethics of Writing About Real-Life Horror in Fiction

Writer's picture: Bryan AlaspaBryan Alaspa

Horror fiction has always drawn inspiration from reality. The most chilling and unforgettable stories often stem from true-life horrors—murders, disasters, atrocities, and unspeakable crimes. Writers have long used real-world events as the foundation for terrifying narratives, but with that comes a significant ethical responsibility. How do authors balance storytelling with sensitivity? When does inspiration cross the line into exploitation? And how can horror writers navigate these murky waters while still crafting impactful fiction?


1. The Fine Line Between Inspiration and Exploitation


Writing about real-life horror can add a sense of authenticity to a story, making it more visceral and unnerving. However, there is a fine line between drawing inspiration from reality and exploiting real suffering for shock value or entertainment.


One of the biggest concerns is respect—especially when writing about recent or ongoing tragedies. Families of victims, survivors, and communities affected by real-life horror may find fictionalized versions of their pain deeply offensive. Even if an author intends to raise awareness or explore the psychological impact of trauma, it’s essential to consider whether the story treats its real-life counterpart with the dignity it deserves.


Questions Writers Should Ask Themselves:


  • Am I telling this story to provoke thought, or simply to shock?

  • Have I done enough research to portray events accurately and responsibly?

  • Would the people affected by this event find my portrayal exploitative or insensitive?


2. Using Real Tragedy to Make a Statement


Many horror writers aim to explore societal issues through their work. Stephen King, Shirley Jackson, and even contemporary horror authors like Paul Tremblay and Alma Katsu use horror as a vehicle to critique real-world fears—racism, oppression, violence, and systemic injustice.

Writing about real-life horror doesn’t always mean exploitation. If done carefully, it can shed light on dark corners of history, giving voice to the silenced. Fictionalizing these events can allow readers to engage with painful truths in a way that pure nonfiction often fails to achieve. The key is to ensure that the story serves a greater purpose beyond mere entertainment.


3. Consent, Research, and Accuracy


When writing about historical or ongoing horror, thorough research is crucial. Misrepresenting an event or group of people can lead to harmful stereotypes, misinformation, or erasure of important facts.


Considerations for Ethical Research:


  • Primary Sources: If possible, read accounts from survivors, experts, or those directly impacted.

  • Respect Privacy: Avoid detailing events that involve living victims without their consent.

  • Sensitivity Readers: Consult individuals who can offer perspective on whether your portrayal is appropriate and accurate.


4. The Role of Fiction in Processing Trauma


Horror fiction can provide catharsis, helping both writers and readers process traumatic events. Stories based on real-life horrors can serve as allegories, allowing people to explore their fears in a controlled environment.


For example, the rise of folk horror often reflects cultural anxieties, while cosmic horror embodies existential dread. More recently, horror has been used to confront racial trauma (Lovecraft Country), gender-based violence (The Last House on Needless Street), and historical atrocities (The Hunger). The key difference between these stories and exploitative horror is how they frame the subject matter—with empathy, depth, and purpose rather than shallow shock value.


5. The Responsibility of Horror Writers


Horror is, by nature, an unsettling genre. It thrives on discomfort, fear, and the uncanny. But that doesn’t mean writers shouldn’t consider the impact of their work. Responsible horror writers should:


  • Acknowledge the Real-Life Source: If a story is based on a real event, consider including a note acknowledging the history and the people involved.

  • Avoid Profiting Off Pain: If writing about a tragedy, consider donating a portion of proceeds to charities related to the subject matter.

  • Be Willing to Revise: If feedback suggests that a portrayal is problematic, be open to making changes.


Conclusion: Horror with a Conscience


Writing horror based on real-life events is a powerful but delicate endeavor. When done ethically, it can bring awareness, provide catharsis, and create thought-provoking art. However, writers must always ask themselves whether they are honoring the reality of the horror they depict or merely capitalizing on it.


As horror writers, we wield a unique power: the ability to make readers confront their deepest fears. With that power comes the responsibility to ensure that the fears we explore serve a purpose—one that respects, informs, and ultimately elevates the genre rather than cheapens it.


What are your thoughts? Have you encountered horror fiction that walked the ethical tightrope successfully? Let’s discuss in the comments!


For my latest psychological horror tale, Newcomers, visit Amazon today!

Or you can visit my online bookstore for all of my work in all formats.

20 views0 comments

Comments


© 2016 by Guffawing Dog Publishing. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page