Forgotten Towns: Horror in the Places That Don’t Exist Anymore

I love abandoned towns in horror. Used it a few times in my own writing. To me, small towns are inherently creepy to begin with, but you find an abandoned one and the ideas can be limitless.

There’s something uniquely eerie about a place that once was, a town that had a name, streets, homes, maybe even a bustling population... and now, it’s gone. Whether swallowed by nature, erased by disaster, or abandoned due to something more mysterious, forgotten towns are ripe with horror potential. These aren’t just ghost towns. These are places where reality seems thin, where time feels warped, and where silence stretches on too long.

For horror writers and readers alike, these places present the ultimate setting: isolated, enigmatic, and already steeped in loss. When no one even remembers the name of a town, what might still linger there?

Why Forgotten Towns Are So Disturbing

Unlike standard ghost towns (which are often preserved for tourism or historical curiosity), truly forgotten towns have slipped into obscurity. You can’t find them on maps anymore. Locals speak of them in hushed tones. Their histories are fragmented, sometimes even denied.

What makes these places so compelling in horror is that they’re already soaked in mystery. They become blank canvases for dread. And when people stumble across them, by accident or design, they often find far more than they bargained for.

Let’s break down why these locations resonate so strongly in horror storytelling:

1. Isolation Without Context

Many horror stories rely on isolation to build fear. Forgotten towns offer a kind of double isolation, not only are they far from civilization, but they’re also cut off from history and memory. You’re alone, and no one even knows where you are.

2. Blurred Boundaries of Reality

When a town is lost to time, the lines between the real and unreal start to fray. Did this place ever exist? Are the buildings hallucinations? Are the people who live here real, or echoes? Forgotten towns often feel like dreamscapes where reality loops, breaks, or bleeds.

3. Urban Legends Come to Life

Many horror authors draw inspiration from real-life vanishing towns or folklore about places that disappeared overnight. These stories give forgotten towns an almost mythic quality, perfect for horror fiction to build upon.

Real-World Inspirations

Some of the best horror settings draw on reality, and there are real-world examples that feel like horror stories waiting to happen.

Centralia, Pennsylvania

This mining town was abandoned after an underground coal fire began burning in the 1960s. The fire still smolders beneath the ground today. Streets go nowhere. Smoke rises from cracks in the earth. Many believe the town inspired Silent Hill.

Dudleytown, Connecticut

An actual place, now off-limits, Dudleytown is steeped in tales of curses, madness, and strange disappearances. Though much of the lore has been debunked, the mythos around it remains potent horror fuel.

Helltown, Ohio

Another heavily mythologized location, this partially abandoned area is tied to legends of mutant creatures, government experiments, and religious cults. None confirmed, but the fear is real.

These places prove the point: when a town’s history is murky or disputed, imagination rushes in to fill the gaps, and horror thrives there.

Forgotten Towns in Horror Fiction

While not the most commonly used setting, forgotten towns pop up in horror fiction from time to time, and when they do, it’s unforgettable.

Silent Hill (Franchise)

Arguably the definitive horror town. A place shrouded in fog, grief, and monsters. The brilliance of Silent Hill is that it changes depending on who enters, tailoring its horrors to individual guilt and trauma. It’s not just forgotten—it wants to be.

Harvest Home by Thomas Tryon

A man and his family move to an idyllic village in New England, but discover the town holds ancient, brutal rituals. While not “forgotten” in the traditional sense, it’s cloistered from the modern world, a pocket of horror preserved in time.

The Borderlands (aka Final Prayer) (2013 film)

An investigation into a remote church uncovers a village sitting atop something deeply unholy. The town itself becomes a character, its normality only a mask for the horror lying just beneath.

The Town That Dreaded Sundown (1976 & 2014)

Both versions explore a town haunted by past violence, and its attempt to bury that history. The idea of forgetting becomes a kind of self-preservation that ultimately fails.

How to Use Forgotten Towns in Your Horror Writing

If you’re a horror author, forgotten towns are like a free sandbox: eerie, mysterious, and versatile. Here’s how to use them effectively:

1. Build a History—Then Bury It

Create a fictional town with a believable history: a founding date, industries, cultural quirks. Then wipe it from the record. Let your characters (and readers) uncover fragments of its past like archaeologists in a psychological minefield.

2. Use Geography as an Antagonist

The town itself should feel alive. Roads that loop. Buildings that shift. Signs that vanish. Give the place agency, it doesn’t want to be found. Or worse, it wants to be found, and it has plans.

3. Play with Time

Forgotten towns often feel unstuck in time. Use this. Maybe it’s always 1957 there. Maybe no one has aged in decades. Or the sun never sets. Time distortion adds to the unease and reinforces the “unreal” quality.

4. Let Memory Become a Weapon

Characters could begin to forget their own lives, or misremember events. Or perhaps the town manipulates memories, twisting what the protagonist believes to be true. Horror rooted in the loss of self and reality is always powerful.

A Map to Nowhere, a Story to Remember

Forgotten towns sit at the crossroads of nostalgia and nihilism. They are places that once mattered, but no longer do, and that void, that absence, is what makes them fertile ground for horror. They are haunted not by ghosts, but by silence, secrecy, and the sense that something was left unresolved.

For horror readers and writers, these places challenge us to imagine what lurks in the spaces history has forgotten. Because if a place can disappear so completely… maybe you can, too.

My newest novel is out now and it's a cult horror tale called The Given!

Or you can visit my online bookstore and find all of my stories in all of your favorite formats.