Forgotten Gods: Tapping Into Ancient Deities for Modern Terror

In the pantheon of horror tropes, monsters, ghosts, and serial killers get a lot of the spotlight, but there’s something especially unsettling about ancient, forgotten gods. These are not your benevolent sky-fathers or mother goddesses. These are beings of chaos, vengeance, and madness. As a horror writer, delving into the world of ancient and obscure deities offers a deep well of inspiration, and an eerie realism that chills to the bone.

Why Forgotten Gods Are Perfect for Horror

Humanity has always feared the unknown, and what’s more unknown than a god that has been lost to time? These deities often represent forces we cannot control or understand: pestilence, chaos, cosmic entropy. Unlike modern gods of morality and order, forgotten gods are primal and uncaring. They exist not to guide, but to endure, and if they awaken, it’s rarely good news for the mortals in their path.

This makes them perfect antagonists or central mysteries in horror fiction. Their motivations are inscrutable. Their power is immense. And best of all, because they’re often fictionalized or loosely inspired by myth, writers have total freedom to reinvent or expand upon them.

Notable Examples in Horror Fiction

While Lovecraft’s Cthulhu Mythos is the most obvious example, filled with elder gods that slumber beneath oceans or between stars, it’s far from the only one.

In The Ritual by Adam Nevill (and its excellent film adaptation), a group of hikers encounters a terrifying Norse deity in the woods of Sweden. It’s not Odin or Thor, but something older, weirder, and much more malevolent. That tension between familiar myth and forgotten horror adds an extra layer of dread.

In Brian Lumley’s Titus Crow series, the Mythos is reimagined with new, lesser-known deities. Even modern films like The Empty Man or The Blair Witch Project hint at arcane forces that are worshipped in secret, beings that demand sacrifice, not prayer.

Creating Your Own Forgotten God

As a horror writer, creating your own forgotten god can open doors to terrifying originality. Here's a simple framework:

1. Domain – What is this god the deity of? Disease? Abandonment? Rust? Choose something offbeat or abstract—it’s creepier that way.

2. Mythology – Was it worshipped in secret? Did it demand a terrible price from its followers? How was it banished or forgotten?

3. Iconography – Describe its appearance in unsettling ways. Think of symbols, statues, rituals. It doesn’t have to make sense—it has to unnerve.

4. Manifestation – How does it influence the modern world? Through dreams? Possession? Weird weather? Maybe it uses the internet or hitchhikes in genetic memory.

5. Cult – Is there a secret group trying to bring it back? Have they already succeeded?

By answering these, you create something that feels ancient and grounded, yet wholly original. The deity becomes a story engine for horror—driving madness, chaos, and tragedy through every page.

Themes to Explore

Writing about forgotten gods allows you to explore big, resonant themes. Here are a few ideas:

• Insignificance – What if we’re just ants in a world built by giants who no longer care?

• Forbidden Knowledge – What happens when a character learns the truth about a god that humanity forgot on purpose?

• Madness – Interacting with a truly ancient, alien deity could shatter your mind. That’s good horror.

• Faith Gone Wrong – What kind of person would worship a god like this? What kind of community would form around that belief?

These themes not only evoke fear, they also resonate with readers on a deeper level. They ask unsettling questions about history, belief, and the thin line between civilization and chaos.

Bringing It Into the Modern World

A great way to make this kind of horror feel fresh is by placing it firmly in the modern world. A cult could organize on social media. A long-lost temple could be discovered via satellite imagery. A tech startup could accidentally feed the sleeping god’s consciousness through an AI training dataset. The tension between ancient and modern makes for fertile horror ground.

Writing Tips for Forgotten God Horror

1. Imply More Than You Explain – The less we know, the more we fear. Drop hints. Let the horror linger in the shadows.

2. Use Firsthand Accounts – Diaries, found footage, recovered documents—these formats amplify the realism and mystery.

3. Keep the Tone Oppressive – These gods should feel inevitable, heavy, and indifferent to human concerns.

4. Play With Reality – The more a forgotten god warps the world around it, the scarier it becomes. Time loops, false memories, dreams bleeding into waking life—all great tools.

Final Thoughts

Forgotten gods are a goldmine of potential for horror fiction. They blend the cosmic with the psychological, the ancient with the modern. Their stories feel larger than life, yet intimately terrifying. Whether you create your own or twist existing myths into something fresh, these beings offer fertile ground for storytelling that sticks with readers long after they’ve closed the book or screen.

If you’re a horror writer looking to push beyond zombies, ghosts, and masked killers, consider letting something ancient and hungry slip through the cracks of your world. Just be careful. You might not be able to forget it afterward.

My latest novel is a cult horror tale and it's called The Given, which is out now!

Or you can visit my online bookstore and see all of my work in all formats in one place.